Ex parte SUZUKI - Page 11




          Appeal No. 1997-1766                                                        
          Application No. 08/245,033                                                  


          Kitagishi '602 and Maruyama.  We note that none of these                    
          references are concerned with zoom lens systems.  Furthermore,              
          we note that none of the optical systems are concerned with a               
          five separate lens units.                                                   
               Yamazaki discloses a three-unit, fixed focal length                    
          telephoto lens that moves the middle lens unit in a direction               
          perpendicular to the optical axis for image stabilization.                  
          Yamazaki does not teach a zoom lens and does not even disclose              
          a five-unit lens.                                                           
               Maruyama also does not teach a zoom lens and does not                  
          even teach a five-unit lens.  Maruyama teaches a four-unit,                 
          fixed focal length telephoto lens.  Maruyama teaches that the               
          second or third lens unit of the four-unit lenses is                        
          decentered for image stabilization.                                         
               Kitagishi '602 discloses a two-unit, fixed focal length                
          telephoto lens embodiment that moves the rear lens unit in a                
          direction perpendicular to the optical axis for image                       
          stabilization and also discloses a three-unit fixed focal                   
          length telephoto lens that moves the middle lens unit in the                
          direction perpendicular to the optical axis for image                       
          stabilization.  We note that Kitagishi '602 discloses in                    

                                        -11-                                          




Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007