Ex parte SPECTOR - Page 7




          Appeal No. 1998-0235                                       Page 7           
          Application No. 08/709,764                                                  


          internal cavity extending inwardly from the crotch of a                     
          projectile.  We agree.  In that regard, while the combined                  
          teachings of the applied prior art may suggest a rubber band                
          be provided in an internal cavity extending inwardly from the               
          crotch of a projectile, the combined teachings of the applied               
          prior art do not teach or suggest using a condom spring in an               
          internal cavity extending inwardly from the crotch of a                     
          projectile.  In our view, the teachings of Flora are not                    
          sufficient for a person of ordinary skill in the art at the                 
          time the invention was made to have replaced either the                     
          elastic spring of Uhrig (i.e., spring g) or the elastic spring              
          of Fortunato (i.e., rubber band 16) with a condom spring as                 
          recited in the claims under appeal (i.e., a condom having a                 
          ring mounted at the front end of the cavity (an internal                    
          elongated cavity formed in the torso having an open front end               
          at the crotch and a closed rear end in an upper region of the               
          torso in line with the head)) and a stretchable shank                       
          extending from the ring whose normal length is shorter than                 
          the length of the cavity because Flora's pouch is used to                   
          increase pressure in the toy and not as an elastic spring.                  









Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007