Ex parte GIFFORD - Page 20




          Appeal No. 1998-0631                                                        
          Application 07/957,990                                                      

          pressure information no matter which keyboard embodiment is                 
          involved and, so, applies to all keyboard embodiment species                
          (i.e., at least species 1-4).  It is true that figure 4 does                
          not show the processing described at pages 13-14, but                       
          neither do any of the other figures; the figures show the                   
          pressure measurement structure, not the processing.                         
          Therefore, the specification as a whole indicates that the                  
          region averaging and shared characteristic evaluation                       
          applies to all keyboard species, including the elected                      
          species of figure 4.                                                        
               The Examiner's finding "that the Fig. 4 embodiment is                  
          unable to do any sort of 'region averaging' or 'shared                      
          characteristic' evaluation" (OA3) is erroneous to the extent                
          that it finds the structure of figure 4 cannot be used in                   
          connection with software processing to perform the                          
          functions.  As noted, none of the apparatus figures shows                   
          the processing, but the processing could be performed in the                
          microprocessor 43' of figure 5 of species 1.  A program is                  
          clearly capable of classifying the depressed keys                           
          (identified by their scancodes) into "regions" or                           
          "characteristics" and matching it with the pressure                         

                                       - 20 -                                         





Page:  Previous  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  20  21  22  23  24  25  26  27  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007