Ex parte RUMP - Page 7




          Appeal No. 1998-0675                                       Page 7           
          Application No. 08/423,512                                                  


          operation, a new threshold value of a speed of brake pedal                  
          actuation as a product of a factor dependent on the driving                 
          situation and a fixed threshold value.                                      


               The examiner fails to show a teaching or suggestion of                 
          the limitations in the prior art of record.  Reichelt uses a                
          threshold value of a speed of brake pedal actuation.                        
          Specifically, “it is checked in a first step 1 whether the                  
          actuating speed of the brake pedal v  has exceeded a                        
                                              BP                                      
          predetermined first threshold value v       .  Col. 2, ll. 62-              
                                               BPthreshold1                           
          65.  Although v       is used, it is not determined during                  
                         BPthreshold1                                                 
          operation, let alone determined as a product of inter alia a                
          factor dependent on a driving situation.  To the contrary, the              
          first threshold value is “predetermined.”  Id. at l. 64.                    
          Specifically, v       is predetermined based on an “order of                
                         BPthreshold1                                                 
          magnitude of ... the maximum possible brake pedal angle.”  Id.              
          at ll. 65-68.  The predetermined first threshold value is “the              
          only criterion for initiating an automatic braking operation                
          ....”  Col. 5, ll. 7-8.                                                     










Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007