Ex parte SUTHA et al. - Page 8




          Appeal No. 1998-1110                                                        
          Application No. 08/391,263                                                  


          "2" and "4." Following that example of a first aggregate, the               
          claimed "second aggregate" may be seen, for example, in Fig.                
          13(d) as comprising the set of picture elements {2,4,6,8}, or               
          {10,12,14,16}, etc. Such a "second aggregate" includes a copy               
          of more than one of the first aggregates, e.g. "24" and "68."               
          Upon a careful review of Nickerson et al., Daher, and                       
          Adams et al., we fail to find that these references teach or                
          suggest "parallel aggregation" as the term is defined by                    
          Appellants, whether it be aggregation of a copy of more than                
          one picture element into a "first aggregate," or aggregation                
          of a copy of more than one "first aggregate" into a "second                 
          aggregate."  We agree with the Examiner that Nickerson et al.               
          teaches transforming a first representation of an information               
          pattern into a second representation of the information                     
          pattern.  We agree with the Examiner that Daher teaches row                 
          and column wise compression of image data where a copy of one               
          or more original picture elements is maintained in the "first               
          compression means." We agree with the Examiner that Adams et                
          al. teaches the compression of image data in a parallel                     
          manner.  We fail to find, however, that any reference teaches               
          parallel aggregation of picture elements or prior aggregates                
                                          8                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007