Ex parte SUTHA et al. - Page 9




          Appeal No. 1998-1110                                                        
          Application No. 08/391,263                                                  


          in such a fashion that the new aggregate includes a copy of                 
          more than one (i.e., at least two) picture element or prior                 
          aggregate, respectively.                                                    
          Nickerson et al. teaches at column 4, lines 14-32                           
          averaging four neighboring data values to obtain a new value                
          that is moved to a new position, and discarding the old                     
          values.  The Examiner concedes that Nickerson et al. does not               
          disclose parallel aggregation.                                              
          Daher teaches at column 8, lines 3-21 image compression                     
          where a copy of one or more picture elements is maintained in               
          the compressed version of the image.  Specifically, Daher                   
          teaches "selecting at least one row from the image data 12 for              
          inclusion in the resized image data 22, and means 52b for                   
          selecting at least one pixel 14 within each selected row for                
          inclusion in the resized image data 22."  Read in combination               
          with Figure 4, this language arguably teaches aggregation of                
          picture elements into first aggregates.  Daher certainly                    
          contains no teaching, however, of second means for parallel                 
          aggregation, with second aggregates each including a copy of                
          more than one first aggregate.                                              


                                          9                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007