Ex Parte DORST et al - Page 6




             Appeal No. 1998-1733                                                                                     
             Application No. 07/617,303                                                                               


             instant claims are directed to practical applications of computer-implemented methods                    
             and apparatus for planning a physical path for a physical object to follow in a physical                 
             task space and/or determining a physical motion specification for a physical object.                     
             While mathematical algorithms may be involved in the processing of data to update a                      
             configuration space data structure, the “essential characteristic” of the subject matter,                
             or its “practical utility,” is to plan a physical path for an object to follow in a physical task        
             space and/or to determine a physical motion specification for a physical object.  Cost                   
             waves are propagated wherein cost values representing physical aspects of the                            
             physical task space with respect to physical motion of the physical object are                           
             generated.  Further, the claimed method and apparatus involve a physical element in                      
             the form of a computer readable storage medium.  This is clear from the language of                      
             independent claims 1, 3, 22 and 33.                                                                      
                    Independent apparatus claims 22 and 33 are in means-plus-function format and                      
             it is clear from the disclosure that these “means” refer to the software embodiment                      
             disclosed.  The computer program provides for the claimed functions and, like the                        
             method claims, claims 22 and 33 are directed to a practical application of any                           
             mathematical algorithms recited.  That is, the claims are directed to the planning of a                  




             path for an object to follow in a physical task space by assigning cost values and                       

                                                          6                                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007