Ex parte ERDOL et al. - Page 7




               Appeal No. 1998-2379                                                                      
               Application No. 08/315,942                                                                


               electromagnetic radiation such as microwave energy or                                     
               police radar energy (Abstract).                                                           
                     As motivation for combining the teachings of Martin                                 
               and Andrews, the examiner states that “[i]t would have                                    
               been obvious to one having ordinary skill in the art at                                   
               the time the invention was made to use the basic radar                                    
               components of Martin et al. and also that EAS markers are                                 
               conventionally used with radar systems, since Martin et                                   
               al. provide for ‘reliable solid-state transmitters’ in c.                                 
               1, lines 10-20, and for improved ‘radar range coverage’                                   
               in the abstract, and because Andrews provides for a radar                                 
               anti-theft system                                                                         
               in the abstract, and for easily attachable EAS devices                                    
               and for their deactivation in c. 1, lines 5-23.”                                          
               (Answer, pages 3-4).                                                                      
                     The examiner cited Tuteur and Frisch because they                                   
               employ wavelet transforms in the use of signal detection.                                 
               According to the examiner (answer, page 6), “[i]t would                                   
               have been obvious to one having ordinary skill in the art                                 
               at the time the invention was made to use the wavelet                                     
               transform of Tuteur, since he provides for adaptively                                     
                                                   7                                                     





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007