Ex parte MULLER - Page 7




         Appeal No. 1998-2709                                                      
         Application No. 08/451,796                                                


         Appellant also argues that the circuit in Albers will                     
         eventually result in cyclic repetition [brief, page 4].                   
              With respect to the second argument, we are not persuaded            
         by this argument.  Albers teaches forming a random number by              
         combining the outputs of two different pseudo-random number               
         generators.  While appellant is correct that the output in                
         Albers will eventually repeat, we do not agree that this                  
         result is precluded by the language of claim 5.  The pseudo-              
         random numbers generated in Albers are considered to be                   
         “random numbers” within the broad definition of that term as              
         it is typically used in this art.                                         
              We do not agree with appellant’s argument that Albers                
         teaches away from using two different types of random number              
         generators.  Although the preferred embodiment of Albers uses             
         two                                                                       


         pseudo-random sequence generators clocked at different                    
         frequencies, the teachings of Albers are not so limited.  It              
         is clear from the disclosure of Albers that the main                      
         requirement of that invention is that the outputs from the two            
         random number generators must be different.  This provides an             
                                         7                                         





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007