Ex parte HAIMI-COHEN et al. - Page 10




          Appeal No. 1998-2974                                                        
          Application No. 08/524,106                                                  


          Larkey would have suggested one such arrangement.  The                      
          reference teaches an inventive “speech recognition apparatus                
          and method.”  Col. 1, ll. 11-12.  I agree with the majority                 
          that “Larkey appears to disclose the claimed method steps of                
          providing an input signal ..., transmitting an output signal                
          comprising more than one approximation of the input signal,                 
          and confirming one of the approximations ....”  Furthermore,                
          Larkey mentions several advantages of its invention.                        
          Specifically, “a primary object of the invention is to improve              
          the recognition accuracy in a speech recognition environment.               
          Other objects of the invention are a dynamic reference pattern              
          updating mechanism for improving the precision with which                   
          incoming unknown speech can be identified, and providing                    
          reference patterns which better characterize a speaker's                    
          manner of pronouncing a selected word vocabulary.”  Col. 1,                 
          ll. 49-56.  Because employing Larkey’s speech recognition                   
          apparatus and method in Daudelin’s speech recognition                       
          environment, i.e., its telecommunications network, would have               
          improved recognition accuracy, improved identification                      
          precision, and better characterized a speaker's manner of                   
          pronunciation, I am persuaded that the prior art as a whole                 
                                         10                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007