Ex parte HASHIMOTO et al. - Page 8




              Appeal No. 1999-2019                                                                                     
              Application No. 08/646,810                                                                               

              document 13 is placed.  A line sensor 1 is supported by a carriage unit 4, which is moved                
              by motor section 8.  The line sensor is driven to scan the original document between                     
              leading edge P2 and trailing edge P3.  Position detector circuit 9, in concert with rotary               
              encoder 8c in motor section 8, supplies information regarding the displacement of line                   
              sensor 1 with respect to a reference position P0.                                                        
                     As shown in the flowchart of Figure 6 and described at column 11, lines 34 through                
              40, the line sensor 1 is moved to position P1 before scanning commences.  Also, as                       
              appellants acknowledge, Kojima discloses performing image exposure while the object                      
              (document 13) and the image pickup device (line sensor 1) are in relative motion, as                     
              illustrated by Kojima’s Figure 8.                                                                        
                     We, unlike appellants, consider Kojima’s description of “initial calibration” to be               
              relevant, in view of the broad recitations of instant claim 10.  The claim sets forth a                  
              discriminator which discriminates “whether a relative movement” is executed between the                  
              object and the image pickup device, which is fairly descriptive of the “initial calibration” and         
              position detection described by Kojima.  Claim 10 also sets forth a controller which                     
              controls writing and/or reading devices such that writing and/or reading of the image signal             
              is performed “during a relative movement.”  Kojima discloses that writing and/or reading                 
              occurs with respect to buffer memory 7 (Fig.1) during the “relative movement” related to the             
              actual scanning; see, for example, column 18, lines 47-54.  Claim 10 ends with the clause                
              “wherein the image pickup device is exposed after a relative movement is completed.”                     

                                                          -8-                                                          





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007