Ex parte HILLIS et al. - Page 9




              Appeal No. 1999-2375                                                                                     
              Application No. 08/892,822                                                                               


                     Appellants argue that there is no suggestion to combine the teachings of the prior                
              art references at pages 8-11 of the brief.  We have addressed this argument with respect                 
              to the individual groups of claims.                                                                      
                     Appellants argue the teachings of the references individually at page 11 of the brief.            
              Since these arguments do not consider the combination of teachings, these arguments are                  
              not persuasive.  Appellants argue that decompression is only done when space is                          
              available.  (See brief at page 11.)  Again, we find no support in the language of the                    
              independent claims for this argument.  Therefore, this argument is not persuasive.                       
              Appellants argue that one of the most distinguishing features of the appellants’ innovation              
              is the reliance of the invention on functional organization, and not address organization.               
              (See brief at page 11.)  We find no support for this argument in the language of the                     
              independent claims; therefore, this argument is not persuasive.   Appellants argue that they             
              have set forth “the uniquely packed BIOS” and have resulted in time and cost savings.                    
              (See brief at page 12.)  Again, we find no support for these arguments in the language of                
              the independent claims; therefore, these arguments are not persuasive.                                   










                                                          9                                                            





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007