Ex parte HIRSCHAUER et al. - Page 8




          Appeal No. 1999-2590                                                        
          Application 08/618,120                                                      


               Turning to Hobbins, we find that Hobbins supports the                  
          teaching of a wire screen attached across the surface of a                  
          cathode ray tube (CRT) and we reference these specific cites                
          from Hobbins.  Hobbins at column 5, lines 5-7, provides:                    
               A conductive screen 22 is provided which has a larger                  
               extent than the viewing area of cathode ray tube 16.                   
               Conductive screen 22 is then placed firmly and tautly                  
               over the viewing surface of the cathode ray tube 16.                   
          Hobbins, at column 5, lines 18-21, provides:                                
               In one embodiment of this invention, conductive adhesive               
               or glue is applied to that portion of conductive screen                
               22 which is contained within [the] groove.                             
          Finally, Hobbins, column 3, lines 26-32, states:                            
               In the preferred embodiment, conductive screen 22 is a                 
               woven wire mesh which readily allows passage of the image              
               projected onto the face 16A of CRT 16 therethrough.  In                
               the most preferred embodiment, conductive screen 22 is a               
               woven wire mesh comprising a matrix of small openings                  
               having a diameter of approximately one thousandth of                   
               inch.                                                                  
               But, we do not find that Hobbins teaches an LED array.                 
          Hobbins teaches the use of a video display and specifically, a              
          CRT unit.  Even if we were to analogize the CRT to an LED                   
          array, Hobbins teaches only one CRT, and Appellants’ claim                  
          language plainly requires “a plurality of module block LED                  
          arrays.”  We do not find that Hobbins teaches or otherwise                  

                                          8                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007