Ex parte TOWFIQ - Page 8




          Appeal No. 1999-2720                                                        
          Application No. 08/580,965                                                  
          to add the new revision intact, and replace the previous                    
          revision with a reverse delta, and maintain the rest of the                 
          old deltas.                                                                 
          Therefore, Tichy teaches a version methodology that limits                  
          space usage with deltas, and limits processing time with the                
          use of reverse deltas.                                                      
               This disclosure is then contrasted by Appellant6 with the              
          disclosure of Ambriola.  He notes that Ambriola discloses                   
          employing complete revision copies.  This reference discloses               
          a version control system named Cedar, which includes a                      
          "bringover command" and a "storeback command."  The bringover               
          command takes the description files and copies all the                      
          referenced files onto the user's personal computer.  When the               
          user completes changes, the changed files are copied back.                  
          Ambriola states7 that the Cedar mechanisms for VC are not very              
          advanced and that no attempts are made to apply space-saving                
          mechanisms.                                                                 
               Consequently, Appellant asserts that since Tichy has no                
          need for, nor suggests a version control system that uses                   


               6Brief, page 5                                                         
               7Page 308, column 1, line 34 et seq.                                   
                                          8                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007