GODDARD v. GAMBARO - Page 10




                    3.     Goddard Controller Model 2                                                                 
                    Mr. Goddard is said to have begun construction of controller model, Model 2, on about             
             January 24, 1989.3  (Goddard=s Brief, p. 6, Goddard Declaration, & 12; Champion Declaration,             
             & 9, emphasis added).  The overall design for controller Model 2 is presented in Goddard                 
             notebook pages 30 and 31 which are marked as Goddard Exhibits J14 and J15.  Exhibit J15                  
             depicts controller Model 2 as possessing a thumb-pad having a keypad.                                    
                           4.     Goddard Controller Model 3                                                          
                    On about February 13, 1989, Mr. Goddard is said to have begun making controller                   
             Model 3, which possessed a thumb pad concavity just to the left of the grip portion. (Goddard=s          
             Brief, p. 6, Goddard Declaration, & 14; Champion Declaration, & 10, emphasis added).  A                  
             photograph of controller Model 3 is provided as Goddard Exhibit J4.4  According to the brief,            
             Aone can clearly see the metallic key positions located in the concavity where they are thumb            
             actuated.@  (Goddard=s Brief, p. 7, Goddard Declaration, & 14; Champion Declaration, & 10).  As          
             depicted in Exhibit J4, there does appear to be a metallic device, i.e., thumb tacks, in a thumb         
             pad.   Interestingly, in response to an interrogatory regarding fabrication of a device with actual      
             switches, Goddard stated that:                                                                           
                           The metallic devices inserted in Model 3 were capable of carrying                          
                           current, and thus functioning as a device for making, breaking, or                         
                           changing the connections in an electrical circuit.  The date of                            
                           Model 3 was on or about February 13, 1989.                                                 

             (Goddard Record, p. 21, Goddard Answers to Written Interrogatories, Interrogatory No. 8).                


                           5.     Goddard Controller Model 4                                                          
                    Continuing to work on the controller device design, Goddard is said to have begun                 
             making controller Model 4 on about February 23, 1989.5  (Goddard=s Brief, p. 7, Goddard                  

                    3 Goddard does not appear to have mentioned an exact date of completion for the                   
             construction of the Model 2 controller.                                                                  
                    4 Goddard=s brief does not appear to have provided a exact date of completion for the             
             construction of his Model 3 controller.  In the photograph of Model 3, Exhibit J4, there is a piece      
             of paper with a date of February 13, 1989.  Furthermore, the declaration of Mr. Jeffrey S.               
             Caldwell verifies that the photograph depicted in Goddard Exhibit J4 was taken in early 1989.            
             (Caldwell Declaration, &4).                                                                              
                    5 Goddard=s brief does not appear to have provided a exact date of completion for the             
             construction of his Model 4 controller.  In the photograph of Model 4, Exhibit J5, there is a piece      

             10                                                                                                       





Page:  Previous  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007