CHARLTON v. ROSENSTEIN - Page 2




               The board has received CHARLTON'S SUBMISSION OF ARBITRATION            
          AWARD, accompanied by a DECISION ON ARBITRATION PURSUANT TO 37              
          CFR 1.690 (Paper 152).  According to the decision on arbitration,           
          "priority of invention is awarded to Charlton, the junior party"            
          (Paper 152, pages 15-16).  We construe the arbitration award to             
          hold that Charlton established priority vis-a-vis Rosenstein and            
          therefore Rosenstein has lost on the issue of priority.                     

               B.   Discussion                                                        
               The sole count in the interference at this time is Count 4             
          (Paper 130, page 2):                                                        
                                       Count 4                                        
                    A test device in accordance with claims 38, 40 or 42 of           
               Charlton application 08/465,675, further provided that said            
               first portion includes a reconstitutable conjugate,                    
               supported therein and mobilizable by transport thereby of              
               the liquid sample,                                                     
                                         or                                           
               a method in accordance with claims 39, 41 or 43 of Charlton            
               application 08/465,675, further provided that said first               
               portion includes a reconstitutable conjugate, supported                
               therein and mobilizable by transport thereby of the liquid             
               sample,                                                                
                                         or                                           
               a test strip in accordance with claims 1 or 11 of Rosenstein           
               patent 5,591,645, or claims 1 or 11 of Rosenstein                      
               application 09/167,028, further provided said tracer site              
               includes a tracer supported thereon such that when liquid is           
               added the tracer becomes mobile and is transported,                    



                                        - 2 -                                         





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007