Appeal No. 1999-0009 Application 08/648,386 deactivating a mode for preventing a facsimile machine from printing when a predetermined number of sequential lines of black data have been stored in its memory. Uetama does not teach a black data reception stop mode that prevents its facsimile apparatus from printing when a predetermined number of sequential lines of black data have been stored in its memory. As explained regarding claims 9, 11-14, and 22, Uetama prints marginal, compressed data when a predetermined number of sequential lines of blank data have been received by the apparatus. Because Uetama prints marginal, compressed data when a predetermined number of sequential lines of blank data have been received, we are not persuaded that the teachings from the applied prior art would have suggested the limitations of “determining whether a black data reception stop mode has been activated while scanning said image data on said document; printing the image data scanned during said scanning step when said black data reception stop mode has not been activated.” Therefore, we reverse the rejection of claims 9, 11-14, and 22 as being obvious over Uetama in view of Horiuchi further in view of 8Page: Previous 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 NextLast modified: November 3, 2007