Ex Parte CELIK - Page 17



          Appeal No. 2000-0467                                                        
          Application 08/511,645                                                      

               reference pertain only to actions which are carried out                
               when the source and destination for the target are                     
               within the same workplace.  They do not suggest that a                 
               move operation is always performed, regardless of the                  
               source of the object.”  See page 8, lines 5-11 of the                  
               Brief.                                                                 
               We note that Appellant’s claim 18 recites the following:               
               determining whether the said second object is a container              
               object;                                                                
               detecting whether there is an indication of a user-initiated           
               modified operation; and                                                
               if said second object is a container object, always                    
               performing a move operation if there is no indication of a             
               user-initiated modified operation, regardless of a source of           
               the first object.                                                      
               In reviewing Appellant’s disclosure, we note that on page 7,           
          line 31 to page 8, line 2 of the specification, Appellant                   
          discloses that, “[i]f the destination is a container object, such           
          as any of the examples illustrated in Figure 3A, the dragged                
          object is moved from its original location to the destination               
          object.”  Appellant further discloses that,                                 
               [o]f course, there may be instances when the user                      
               desires to place a copy of a selected object at the                    
               destination, and leave the original version of the                     
               object intact, rather than move it.  For example,                      
               referring to Figure 3A, the user may desire to place a                 
               copy of the file 54 in the folder 58.  In this                         
               situation, the user can indicate the desire to make a                  
               copy by performing a specified action during the drag-                 
               and-drop operation.  See page 8, lines 10-15 of the                    
               specification.                                                         
                                          17                                          




Page:  Previous  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  20  21  22  23  24  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007