Appeal No. 2000-2111 Application No. 08/860,537 controlling means inquiring about the reproduction speed, we find Nagasawa’s disclosure in column 7, lines 11-22 which state that: When the operator operates a certain reproduction pattern designating operation key of the operation unit 28, commands assigned to operation keys, e.g., various reproduction commands, such as slow motion reproduction, quick motion reproduction, etc., are supplied from the control unit 27 to the storage device 22. When commands indicative of reproducing at various reproduction speeds are supplied to the output interface circuits 23-1, 23-2, ..., 23-k of the storage device 22, the output interface circuits 23-1, 23-2, ..., 23-k of the storage device 22 output sources read from the area Ar1 of the storage device 22 at speeds based on the commands. [Emphasis added.] The recorded video data from the storage area Ar1 is reproduced at a designated reproduction speed that is based on the reproduction commands supplied by input/output control means in control unit 27. Therefore, as discussed above, Nagasawa teaches “the controlling means ... inquires about the reproduction speed,” as recited in claim 1, by disclosing a control unit that controls the recording/reproducing of video data based on a reproduction speed received from the control unit. With respect to claim 2, we note that Nagasawa teaches that audio/video data from storage area Ar1 is supplied through output interface 23 to special effect mixer 25 at the normal transfer rate (first data rate) in response to reproduction control signal NPc (col. 5, lines 7-15). Furthermore, audio/video data from storage area Ar2 is supplied through input interface 24 to high 8Page: Previous 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 NextLast modified: November 3, 2007