Ex Parte SCHUSTER et al - Page 7




          Appeal No. 2001-0345                                                        
          Application 09/041,416                                                      


          sheet depicted in detail in cross-section in Figure 3 and shown             
          to be done at station 34 in Figure 1.                                       
               The discussion at the bottom of column 4 of Raschke                    
          indicates that the belt 10 is intended to be reused as well as              
          the separate corresponding teaching relative to the master sheet            
          itself at the top of column 5.  The examples given at column 5              
          and 6 indicate that the belt 10 and the toner supplies are                  
          respectively charged.                                                       
               Because of the teaching or alternative suggestion at the top           
          of page 3 of Doyle to use a liquid-type toner in place of the               
          powdered toner in this reference, the artisan obviously would               
          have turned to the teachings of Calabrese to ascertain the best             
          methodology of ensuring the application of a liquid toner to the            
          substrate surface.  The discussion at the bottom of column 5,               
          noted by the examiner in the answer, at lines 57-66 directly                
          teaches the thickness of the liquid toner particles is controlled           
          by voltage and/or time of application during a charging step "to            
          obtain satisfactory toning of the electro-static image on the               
          surface."  This paragraph also indicates that it was given to the           
          artisan to determine the optimum conditions, based upon the toner           
          used, and the various process conditions utilized.  Thus, this              


                                          7                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007