Ex Parte TOUZEAU et al - Page 8



          Appeal No. 2001-0656                                                        
          Application No. 08/976,645                                                  

          requires a “channel skip message” rather than a transfer message)           
          to the primary station in order to transfer the communication               
          link to another matched secondary station.  The primary station             
          transmits a release request to the secondary station to which the           
          link has been set up and issues a link establishment request to             
          establish a link with the other matched secondary station.                  
          Accordingly, the claims require the secondary station that is               
          already in communication with the primary station, to go through            
          the primary station in order to transfer the link.                          
               In contrast, Yamashita appears to disclose a chief sub-unit,           
          which is already in communication with the main unit, which does            
          not transmit a transfer request to the main unit, only other sub-           
          units that wish to become the chief sub-unit.  The examiner                 
          points to steps S406 and S409 in Figure 29 of Yamashita.  These             
          steps are concerned with transmitting an assignment signal and              
          changing over the chief sub-unit but we find nothing therein                
          which would contradict appellants’ position that the chief sub-             
          unit changeover means is used by another sub-unit that is not in            
          communication with the main unit.  A sub-unit designates itself             
          as the new chief sub-unit.  There is no communication with the              
          primary station in order to transfer the link to another matched            
          secondary unit, or sub-unit, as required, in one form or another,           
                                         -8–                                          




Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007