Ex Parte WONG et al - Page 2


                 Appeal No. 2001-1027                                                          Page 2                    
                 Application No. 08/442,210                                                                              

                                       (4)  a lead end comprising a convex surface for                                   
                                       eliminating residual drug inside the caplet, which convex                         
                                       surface possesses a radius of curvature equal to, but not                         
                                       exceeding, twice the radius of the cylindrical body, for                          
                                       maximizing the dose of drug delivered from the osmotic                            
                                       caplet; and                                                                       
                                       (5)  a passageway in the convex surface for delivering the                        
                                       drug to the patient.                                                              

                        The examiner relies on the following reference:                                                  
                 Eckenhoff et al. (Eckenhoff)               4,612,186            Sept. 16, 1986                          

                        Claims 1, 2, and 4-15 stand rejected under 35 U.S.C. § 102(b) as                                 
                 anticipated by Eckenhoff.                                                                               
                        We reverse.                                                                                      
                                                      Discussion                                                         
                        The claims are directed to a caplet for delivering a drug to a patient.  The                     
                 claims define a caplet comprising a cylindrical body, a dose of drug, and a                             
                 semipermeable wall.  The claims also state that the caplet has a convex surface                         
                 on the lead end of the caplet, “which convex surface possesses a radius of                              
                 curvature equal to but not exceeding twice the radius of the cylindrical body,” and                     
                 a passageway in the convex surface through which the drug is delivered.  The                            
                 specification makes clear that the convex surface referred to in the claims is a                        
                 curved depression in one end of the caplet.  See the specification, pages 8-9                           
                 (numbers refer to reference numerals in the specification’s Figure 2):                                  
                        Osmotic dosage caplet 10 comprises a dispensing passageway 19                                    
                        that communicates the interior of compartment 15 with the exterior                               
                        of solid dosage caplet 10.  Dispensing passageway 19 is present in                               





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007