Ex Parte ELLIS - Page 2




            Appeal No. 2002-0363                                                                       
            Application No. 08/162,373                                                                 




                  The invention involves “the use of the theoretically ideal stability plane concept to
            provide stability in negative heel shoe soles that are less thick in the heel area than in 
            the rest of the shoe sole” (specification, page 1).  The appellant explains that “the      
            concept of the theoretically ideal stability plane is that the thickness of the contoured  
            stability sides of the shoe soles, typically measured in the frontal plane, should equal   
            the thickness of the shoe sole underneath the foot (specification, page 2).                
            Representative Claim 93 reads as follows:                                                  


                  93.  An athletic shoe sole for a shoe, the athletic shoe sole comprising:            
                        a sole heel area of the athletic shoe sole at a location substantially         
            corresponding to the location of a heel of an intended wearer’s foot when inside the       
            shoe;                                                                                      
                        a sole forefoot area at a location substantially corresponding to the          
            location of a forefoot of an intended wearer’s foot when inside the shoe;                  
                        a sole midtarsal area located between the sole heel area and the sole          
            forefoot area;                                                                             
                        the sole heel, midtarsal, and forefoot areas each having a sole medial         
            side, a sole lateral side, and a sole middle part located between the sole sides, as       
            viewed in a shoe sole frontal plane during a shoe unloaded, upright condition;             


                        a sole inner surface adjacent an intended wearer’s foot location inside the    
            shoe having at least a first concavely rounded portion, said concavity being determined    
            relative to an intended wearer’s foot location inside the shoe, as viewed in a frontal     
            plane located in the sole forefoot area, during an unloaded, upright shoe condition;       
                                                  2                                                    





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007