Ex Parte FEULNER - Page 7



          Appeal No. 2002-0538                                                        
          Application 09/220,468                                                      

          outer shroud of the compressor section substantially adjacent to            
          one row of rotating blades and in fluid communication with the              
          turbine section for extracting air from the tip clearance of the            
          blades to be routed to the turbine section to increase stability            
          of the engine.  Although Uehling does not specify the nature of             
          the interface between the compressor 14 and the pipe 24, it is              
          not disputed that this interface must include at least one                  
          opening in the shroud (housing 12).  Uehling’s Figure 3, which              
          shows bypass pipe 24 communicating with the compressor 14 through           
          the shroud at a position adjacent the tip clearance area of a row           
          of rotating blades, belies the appellant’s argument that “Uehling           
          does not teach that the bleed air is extracted through an opening           
          that is substantially adjacent to a row of rotating blades” (main           
          brief, page 7).  Although patent drawings are not working                   
          drawings, things shown clearly therein are not to be disregarded,           
          even if unexplained by the specification.  In re Mraz, 455 F.2d             
          1069, 1072, 173 USPQ 25, 27 (CCPA 1972).  Due to its position,              
          Uehling’s opening(s) would necessarily extract air from the tip             
          clearance area of the rotating blades, and the resulting                    
          reduction in tip clearance leakage would inherently increase the            
          stability of the engine to the same extent that the extraction of           


                                          7                                           



Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007