Ex Parte CAI et al - Page 5




              Appeal No. 2002-0695                                                                                        
              Application No. 09/132,731                                                                                  


              specified using source language statements and it may assert the need for making the                        
              selection of a “file-system” as easy as possible [reply brief-page 4], it is appellants who                 
              solve this problem by allowing a “file system” to be specified by source language                           
              statements so that a resulting object program includes different instructions for                           
              performing the input and output operations depending on the “file-system” specified by                      
              the source language statements.  The examiner has offered nothing as to why the                             
              claimed file-system identifier provided by the source program statements would be the                       
              same as merely specifying a “file name.”                                                                    
                     The examiner has pointed to nothing within Coker, Archer, or the background                          
              section of the instant specification which convinces us that it was known or would have                     
              been obvious to provide for “wherein at least one of the received statements includes a                     
              file-system identifier that permits selection of a file system for performing input and                     
              output operations in the source program and the file-system identifier is selected from a                   
              group comprising a literal, an environment variable, and a data name; and...compiling                       
              the source program into an object program in the memory of the computer, wherein the                        
              object program includes instructions for performing the input and output operations                         
              according to the file-system identifier that permits the selection of the file system.”                     




                                                  CONCLUSION                                                              

                                                            5                                                             





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007