Ex Parte PAGE - Page 51




               not meet its burden by making a prima facie showing, we need not and have not considered                               
               Cabilly opposition 10.                                                                                                 
                                               Glaxo preliminary motions 1 and 2                                                      
                       Glaxo preliminary motion 1 attacks the priority benefit accorded to Cabilly for the filing                     
               date of the‘457 application for the subject matter of Count 1.  Glaxo preliminary motion 2                             
               attacks the priority benefit accorded to Cabilly for the filing date of the ‘419 application for the                   
               subject matter of Count 1.                                                                                             
                       Since we grant Glaxo’s preliminary motion 5 to the extent it seeks to substitute proposed                      
               Count 2 for Count 1, Glaxo preliminary motions 1 and 2 are DISMISSED as moot.                                          
                                                   Glaxo preliminary motion 4                                                         
                       In its preliminary motion 4, Glaxo moves to have Cabilly claims 56-60 designated as not                        
               corresponding to Count 1.  Since we grant Cabilly preliminary motion 5 to substitute Count 2 for                       
               Count 1, Glaxo preliminary motion 4 is DISMISSED as moot.                                                              
                                                 Glaxo preliminary motions 6-9                                                        
                       In Glaxo preliminary motions 6-9, Glaxo moves to have certain of its involved claims                           
               designated as not corresponding to Count 1.  We grant Glaxo preliminary motion 5 to substitute                         
               Count 2 for Count 1.  Thus, Glaxo preliminary motions 6-9 are DISMISSED as moot.                                       
                       C.      Other Glaxo motions                                                                                    
                                                 Glaxo miscellaneous motion 10                                                        
                       Glaxo miscellaneous motion 10 is treated as a motion to suppress evidence                                      
               (FF 23).  Glaxo moves to suppress Cabilly Exhibits 1090-1091, 1093-1094, 1095, 1095A,                                  
               1095B, 1112, 1113, and 1114 (Paper 176 at 2).  We have not relied upon Cabilly Exhibit 1090-                           

                                                                -51-                                                                  





Page:  Previous  44  45  46  47  48  49  50  51  52  53  54  55  56  57  58  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007