Ex Parte PAGE - Page 52




               1091, 1093-1094, 1095, 1095A, 1095B, 1112, 1113, and 1114 as a basis for our decision.                                 
               Accordingly, we need not and have not decided Glaxo miscellaneous motion 10.  Glaxo                                    
               miscellaneous motion 10 is DISMISSED as moot.                                                                          
                                                 Glaxo miscellaneous motion 11                                                        
                       Glaxo miscellaneous motion 11 is treated as a motion to suppress evidence (FF 23).                             
               Glaxo moves to suppress specific portions of Cabilly Exhibits 1100, 1120, 1121, and 1124                               
               (Paper 177 at 2).  We have not relied upon the portions of Cabilly Exhibits 1100, 1120, 1121,                          
               and 1124 that Glaxo seeks to suppress as a basis for our decision.  Accordingly, we need not and                       
               have not decided Glaxo miscellaneous motion 11.  Glaxo miscellaneous motion 11 is                                      
               DISMISSED as moot.                                                                                                     
                                                 Glaxo miscellaneous motion 12                                                        
                       Glaxo miscellaneous motion 12 is treated as a motion to suppress evidence (FF 23).                             
               Glaxo moves to suppress Cabilly specific portions of Cabilly Exhibits 1100, 1167, 1120, 1169,                          
               1121, 1168, 1124, 1165, 1166, and 1172 (Paper 178 at 2-3).  We have not relied upon the                                
               portions of Cabilly Exhibits 1100, 1167, 1120, 1169, 1121, 1168, 1124, 1165, 1166, and 1172                            
               that Glaxo seeks to suppress as a basis for our decision.  Accordingly, we need not and have not                       
               decided Glaxo miscellaneous motion 12.  Glaxo miscellaneous motion 12 is DISMISSED as                                  
               moot.                                                                                                                  
                               D.      Cabilly preliminary and other motions                                                          
                                                Cabilly preliminary motions 1-6                                                       
                       Cabilly preliminary motions 1-6 seek judgment that the Glaxo involved claims are                               
               unpatentable.  Since Glaxo cannot prevail on priority in the interference, we need not and have                        

                                                                -52-                                                                  





Page:  Previous  44  45  46  47  48  49  50  51  52  53  54  55  56  57  58  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007