YAMADA et al. - Page 18




          object to the evidence submitted by Chern. Furthermore, Yamada            
          did not cross examine Wen-Foo Chern or Trent. Based on the                
          record before us, Yamada has failed to sufficiently demonstrate           
          that the facts presented by Chern are inaccurate.                         
               Yamada further argues that the "third note" of the                   
          handwritten notes attached to the Invention Disclosure form (Ex.          
          2002, R-14) does not describe and is contradictory to what is             
          shown in the "first circuit diagram" (Paper 28 at 17). Yamada             
          fails to sufficiently demonstrate that the third note refers to           
          the "first circuit diagram". Part of the "third note" is a block          
          circuit diagram with annotations that are referenced in the               
          handwritten notes. The same annotations do not appear in the              
          "first circuit diagram". Accordingly, a more reasonable                   
          interpretation of the "third note" is that it refers to that              
          circuit that is part of the "third note" and not the "first               
          circuit diagram". Yamada has failed to sufficiently demonstrate           
          otherwise.                                                                
               Yamada makes several additional arguments regarding (1) the          
          other circuits on the drawing, (2) the handwritten notes on the           
          drawing, (3) the handwritten notes attached to the Invention              
          Disclosure form and, (4) the handwritten notes made on the                
          Invention Disclosure form. Essentially, Yamada argues that the            
          information provided for in items 1-4 is inaccurate, incomplete,          
          inconsistent, and fails to describe the count (Paper 28 at 7-22).         
               The additional arguments made by Yamada regarding items (1)          
                                         18 -                                       







Page:  Previous  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  20  21  22  23  24  25  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007