ZHOU et al. V. KEAGY et al. - Page 15





                                                                                  Interference No. 104,649            
                                                                                              Page No. 12             

                                                                   jr                                                 
                                                         42 43'                                                       
                                                                                     11                               
                                                                                      50                              
                                                                                       6                              
                                                                                   P                                  
                                   53 53' t44                                                                         
                                 42                                                                                   
                             ^48 52                                                                                   
                                   5352 43 49 48 4V                                                                   
                           45                                                                                         
                          Point U& Source                                                                             
                                                        FIG. 6                                                        

             Keagy '969 provides the following description of the ray diagram of Figure 6:                            
                    In FIG. 6, rays 42 and 43 emanate from a point light source 45 at angles such that                
                    they pass through the bottom surface 44 of the plastic platen 46 and reach the                    
                    upper interface surface 50. These rays 42 and 43 happen to fall upon points on                    
                    upper surface 50 in contact with ridges of a finger, and escape the platen and are                
                    lost as rays 42' and 43'. In contrast, rays 52 and 53 reach the top surface and                   
                    impinge upon air in the valleys between fingerprint ridges, and are jpLally                       
                    internally reflected. Their reflected versions, 53' and 52', form part of the white               
                    portions of a working image of the user's fingerprint. Rays 52' and 53' are                       
                    refracted toward the imaging apparatus (not shown) because of the difference in                   
                    indices of refraction between the flesh in a fingerprint ridge and air.                           
             (Keagy '969, col. 7, line 57 to col. 8, line 3). Keagy's description of Figure 6 is confusing in that    
             it appears to use the terms reflected and refracted to describe the same phenomenon.                     


             F22. Keagy's description of rays that bounce off the upper surface of the platen in Figures 3            
             (31, 33 and 35) and 6 52' and 53') is inconsistent with the description of similar rays in Figures       
             5 (3a and 4a) and 7A and 7B. Although inconsistent in the specification, one skilled in the art          







Page:  Previous  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  20  21  22  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007