ZHOU et al. V. KEAGY et al. - Page 18





                                                                                    Interference No. 104,649              
                                                                                                Page No. 15               
               F26. Chen Figure 7B is said to show how the embodiment of Chen Figure 7A works.                            
               Generally, Chen states that a light ray is passed through the platen whereupon it is subjected to          
               "total internal light reflection" in the spaces between the ridges that form a fingerprint. In             
               contrast, where the light ray contacts the sweat on a finger ridge, the light ray is "refracted" and       
               no light returns to form an image. (ZX 2008, col. 4, lines 42-53).                                         


                             B. Sibbald, U.S. Patent No. 5,619,586                                                        
               F27. Sibbald 's describes an apparatus and techniques for the characterization of fingerprints.            
               (ZX 2012, col, 1, lines 12-13). Specifically, it is an object of Sibbald's invention to provide a          
               method of producing an image of a fingerprint that may be viewed without the aid of optical                
               equipment. (ZX 2012, col. 2, lines 1-8).                                                                   


               F28. Sibbald does not describe using reflected light from a plurality of exit surfaces, e.g.,              
               prisms, to create an image of the fingerprint. Instead, Sibbald depicts and describes a fingerprint        
               apparatus employing a direct imaging producing means, such as a ground glass plate or a very               
               thin layer of non-opaque paint. (ZX 2012, Figures 2, 3 and 5, abstract and col. 2, lines 44-47).           


















Page:  Previous  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  20  21  22  23  24  25  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007