Appeal No. 1999-0541 Application No. 08/599,436 argues that shifting the order of the black matrix layer and the conductive layer would not modify the operation of the resulting device (answer, page 7). As the Examiner and Appellants concede, Brodie teaches a basic structure of a flat panel display of the field emission cathode type (Fig. 4 and col. 4, line 61 through col. 5, line 20). On the other hand, a review of Kobale reveals that the reference relates to a luminescent display screen wherein the individual luminescent dots are separated from one another by a matrix of contrasting layer (col. 1, lines 6-11). Kobale teaches that a conductive layer covers both the recesses in the substrate and the contrasting border layer that are formed on the land areas between recesses formed in a substrate (col. 3, lines 44- 54). We further find that the Kobale reference discloses a plurality of functions for the contrasting border layer such as separating the individual luminescent points, improving color contrast, masking the substrate during the application of the luminescence material into the recesses and functioning as aPage: Previous 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 NextLast modified: November 3, 2007