Ex Parte JUNDT - Page 4




          Appeal No. 2000-0396                                                        
          Application No. 08/527,886                                                  


               The original invention disclosed a process control                     
               terminal wherein means are provided for preventing                     
               application data from overwriting process control data                 
               by dedicating two fixed display screen portions for                    
               both application and process control data thereby                      
               preventing the different types of data from overwriting                
               one another.  The reissue application claims to                        
               eliminate the need for a screen portions [sic, portion]                
               to be fixed and dedicated by now allowing the different                
               types of data to share the same screen portions and                    
               then preventing them from sharing the same screen area.                
          The examiner continues that "the original specification clearly             
          sets forth two predetermined screen portions for preventing                 
          interference between application and process data."                         
               Claims 60 and 61 recite that the process control information           
          is displayed on "a first predetermined portion" and the process             
          control information and the application information are displayed           
          on "separate portions."  These recitations suggest to us that the           
          two types of information do not share the same screen portions,             
          but, rather, are displayed on separate predetermined screen                 
          portions.                                                                   
               Likewise, claim 69 recites "a first portion of the display             
          screen reserved for the alarm indication" and application                   
          information being displayed "in portions of the display screen              
          other than the first portion."  Again, the process control data             
          and the application data are in separate predetermined portions             
          of the screen.  Similarly, claim 73 recites first and second                
          portions and a step of "keeping said first portion of said                  

                                          4                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007