Ex Parte CHAURUSHIA et al - Page 6




          Appeal No. 2000-0496                                                        
          Serial No. 08/795,626                                                       
          a point source site within the space where pollution is                     
          originating.                                                                
               The JP ‘212 apparatus has an airborne pollutant collector              
          hose which is shown as appearing flexible and extendably                    
          maneuverable and having a distal end positionable at a point                
          source site of pollutant origin (figures 1(a) and 3(a)).  JP ‘212           
          does not disclose at least one articulatable exterior support               
          structure for the hose.  However, the disclosure by Ray that a              
          conventional gas spring (45) is effective for supporting an air             
          pollutant capture arm (44) at any desirable angular disposition             
          relative to the housing (12) (col. 3, lines 33-38) would have led           
          one of ordinary skill in the art to obtain this benefit in the              
          JP ‘212 apparatus by using such a gas spring to support the hose.           
               The JP ‘212 housing contains a vacuum system (fan 5) in                
          communication with the hose to draw airborne pollutants into the            
          housing through the hose to a filter system (14, 4) (pages 6-7).            
               The JP ‘212 filter system includes a plurality of removable            
          filters (14, 4) within the housing and to which airborne                    
          pollutants drawn into the housing from the hose are delivered to            
          be trapped and retained (pages 7-8).                                        
               The appellants argue that Vross’ metal impingers (39) do not           
          function in the removal of airborne oil, grease and solvent                 
          residues as alleged by the examiner (brief, page 7).  That                  

                                          6                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007