Ex Parte STEPP et al - Page 5




          Appeal No. 2000-1363                                                        
          Application No. 08/848,374                                                  


          configuration information is created.  Also, Harada explains                
          (column 4, lines 60-65) that HDD stores plural sets of                      
          configuration information, "one set corresponding to the latest             
          configuration #1, and others corresponding to other system                  
          configurations (#2, #3, etc.) previously formed and set up."                
          Thus, Harada clearly keeps track of which configuration is the              
          most recent and which configurations were formed previously.                
          Harada further teaches (column 5, lines 23-26) that "[e]ach time            
          the system set up program is run relative to a new system                   
          configuration #j . . . the (setup) program creates associated               
          system configuration information #j which is stored in NVRAM 7."            
          Thus, the configuration settings are indexed in order as they are           
          created, or rather, chronologically.  As to whether Harada stores           
          changes made to the settings, if each setting is saved with the             
          changes made to the previous setting, then the saving of the                
          settings is the same as the saving of the changes.                          
               For claim 16, appellant contends (Brief, page 9) that ASUS             
          and Harada are not combinable and that claim 16 is therefore                
          allowable.  However, nowhere do appellants indicate what claim              
          limitations are lacking from Harada.                                        
               Regarding claim 1, Harada discloses (column 3, lines 40-46)            
          a computer with a CPU 13, a storage device HDD 9, a non-volatile            

                                          5                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007