Ex Parte GARFIELD et al - Page 2


                Appeal No.  2001-0982                                                   Page 2                
                Application No.  08/310,950                                                                   

                      16. A pharmaceutical composition comprising an admixture of (a)                         
                           prostacyclin or prostacyclin analog and at least one of (c) an                     
                           estrogen and (d) a progestin, wherein the amounts of (a) and (c)                   
                           and/or (d) are synergistincally effective and are individually                     
                           ineffective or marginally effective.                                               
                      According to appellants’ dependent claims the prostacyclin or prostacyclin              
                analog may be iloprost (see e.g., claim 7), the progestin may be progesterone                 
                (see e.g., claim 10), and the estrogen may be an estradiol (see e.g., claim 12).              
                As set forth in appellants’ specification (pages 9-10) the method aspect of the               
                invention involves administering a prostacyclin or a prostacyclin analog in a                 
                amount bioequivalent to 0.1-10 ng/kg/min of prostacyclin intravenously, and one               
                or both of a progestin and an estrogen in an amount of estrogen bioequivalent to              
                approximately 2 mg per day of estradiol and an amount of progestin                            
                bioequivalent to 50-300 mg of injected progesterone.  Furthermore, the                        
                specification states (page 10), “[a] synergistic effect is achieved when a                    
                progestational and/or estrogenic agent is administered concurrently with the                  
                prostacyclin or prostacyclin analog.”                                                         
                      The references relied upon by the examiner are:                                         
                Adams et al. (Adams), “Effects of Estrogens and Progestins on Atherosclerosis                 
                in Primates,” in Sex steroids and the cardiovascular system, Schering                         
                Foundation Workshop 5, pp. 161-175 (P. Ramwell et al., eds., Springer Verlag)                 
                (1992)                                                                                        
                Braun et al. (Braun), “Antiatherosclerotic Properties of Oral Cicaprost in                    
                Hypercholesterolemic Rabbits,” Prostaglandins in the Cardiovascular System,                   
                pp 282-288 (1992)                                                                             










Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007