Ex Parte GEORGESON et al - Page 5




              Appeal No. 2001-1340                                                                                      
              Application 08/944,885                                                                                    


              features of the claimed invention.  Specifically, although the examiner has pointed to a                  
              circuit in Hogan for performing various functions including comparison and a display                      
              capable of providing a readout value in any desirable form [answer, page 5], the circuit                  
              of Hogan does not perform the specific function recited in the claimed invention nor                      
              does the display in Hogan display the specific value recited in the claimed invention.                    
                     Each of the claims on appeal recites a step or device for determining if the                       
              impact signal exceeds a threshold value and, if it does, a step or device for measuring                   
              the length of time that the impact signal exceeded that threshold value.  Although                        
              Hogan does determine if a threshold value has been exceeded, Hogan does not                               
              measure the duration of time in which the threshold is exceeded.  Hogan simply                            
              measures the signal for a predetermined time in which it is known that the signal will                    
              have fallen below the threshold so that all critical data will be stored.  Thus, Hogan does               
              not perform the specific claimed step of measuring the length of time that the impact                     
              signal is above the threshold value.  Since Hogan does not determine this elapsed time                    
              value, Hogan also does not display this value.                                                            










                                                           5                                                            





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007