Ex Parte GALLAGHER et al - Page 6



          Appeal No. 2001-1926                                                        
          Application 08/777,722                                                      

          apparent that a plurality of switch nodes exist in Figure 1 of              
          Bales, the examiner has not attempted to correlate teachings and            
          suggestions of Bales to a required first application for                    
          controlling continuously various call functions of wireless calls           
          and separately for controlling in a similar first application               
          separately recited handset functions, both of which are recited             
          to exist initially in claim 12 on appeal in the first recited               
          switch node.  The claim additionally requires at least second               
          handset functions to exist but in a second switch node such as to           
          effect a handoff of handset functions between the first to the              
          second node.  It is thus apparent at the end of the claim on                
          appeal that the control of the call functions themselves remains            
          with the first application stated to exist in the first node such           
          as to continue the control of the wireless call there rather than           
          at the second stated node.                                                  
               Notwithstanding the fact that Figure 1 of Bales clearly                
          shows plural switch nodes 101 and 130, the examiner has made no             
          attempt to correlate these listed recited functions of                      
          representative claim 12 on appeal to the teachings and showings             
          of Bales himself.  Indeed, a labeled TMA functions within both              
          of the switch nodes shown in Figure 1 and relates only to                   
          terminal management application functions, and the TEA portions             
                                          6                                           




Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007