Ex Parte GOLDSCHMIDT IKI et al - Page 13




          Appeal No. 2001-2003                                                        
          Application 08/939,185                                                      


          Additionally, in the context of our earlier discussion, an enter-           
          tainment selection can clearly be TV from the command bar 32 as             
          well as to then select a particular channel.  Additionally, we do           
          not agree with appellants' views that the remote control writing            
          pad information comes in the same format, since the various types           
          of tracings of the stylus and the writing pad enables the user to           
          pre-code any type of broadly definable multimedia data.  One                
          format is iconic information, or pictograms, or handwritten, or             
          printed text, all of which are obviously different formats.                 
               Appellants' arguments as to claim 55 are also misplaced                
          since the examiner's correlation of this claim to the discussion            
          at column 12 and Figures 17-19 is not so clearly misplaced as               
          appellants would have us believe.  The plurality of different               
          multimedia formats are in part representative of the type of                
          indicia that we indicated earlier was taught at columns 7 and 8             
          of Lopresti and of which are depicted in graphical form in Figure           
          17.  Additionally, the ability of Lopresti’s system to                      
          communicate with on-demand services, video libraries, video                 
          games, shopping and the I-mail itself obviously requires the                
          reformatting of information from different sources into a common            
          or unitary data format for use by the hand-held device of                   


                                         13                                           





Page:  Previous  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007