Ex Parte GOLDSCHMIDT IKI et al - Page 4




          Appeal No. 2001-2003                                                        
          Application 08/939,185                                                      


          filed.  Our review of this information indicates it is remarkably           
          expansive in nature as to what various sources of data and                  
          identifiers may comprise yet, at the same time, Lopresti clearly            
          appears to us to anticipate even some of them to the extent                 
          broadly recited in the representative claim 43 on appeal.  The              
          overall context of Lopresti is consistent with what appellants              
          regard as the background of the invention: there is a convergence           
          of computer systems and transitional entertainment systems as               
          recognized at page 7 of the principal brief on appeal.  Column 1            
          of Lopresti indicates in part the availability of "up to 500                
          channels of programming, and a variety of on-demand services,               
          including home shopping and banking, interactive games and                  
          entertainment, multimedia libraries and full access to the                  
          Internet."  (Column 1, lines 19-22).  The paragraph bridging                
          columns 6 and 7 of Lopresti indicates that much of the video user           
          environment is implemented in software, such as that depicted in            
          Figure 6, which "could also be downloaded to random access                  
          memories RAM 74 and RAM 86 over various transmission media,                 
          including but not limited to, standard telephone lines, fiber               
          optic cable, or the television cable that also delivers the video           
          signals."                                                                   


                                          4                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007