Ex Parte LEE - Page 6




          Appeal No. 2001-2106                                                         
          Application No. 08/856,183                                                   


               A review of the applied prior art confirms that Bertram                 
          relates to the use of SCSI bus interface and driver to connect               
          laser printers to computers and move the image rasterization from            
          the printer side to the host computer (page 106, lefthand                    
          column).  According to Bertram, using SCSI removes the need for a            
          specific printer language and insures faster data transfer and               
          screen images that are more consistent with the printed images               
          (page 107, lefthand column).  However, as contended by the                   
          Examiner, Bertram includes nothing related to the claimed print              
          requests received as a series of method invocations using                    
          commands in a Java object oriented language syntax.                          
               JLS, on the other hand, identifies Java as a general-purpose            
          object-oriented programming language and discloses the                       
          specification of the syntax and semantics of Java language (page             
          4).  More specifically, JLS describes the evolution of Java as               
          completely compatible with existing applications wherein Java                
          compilers and systems are capable of supporting the several                  
          different versions of Java simultaneously and with complete                  
          compatibility (id.).  Furthermore, to provide various choices for            
          downloading the language specification, JLS lists HTML, PDF and              
          Postscript as the available download formats on page 1.                      


                                          6                                            





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007