Ex Parte TARANTO et al - Page 7



          Appeal No. 2002-0288                                                        
          Application No. 08/883,241                                                  

          citing column 1, lines 35-37, of Hughes.                                    

               Appellants argue that while Sanderman may teach viewing a              
          hierarchical nodal structure (for example, in Figure 4, showing a           
          display, the contents of folder 204d are displayed, including               
          leaf nodes “movie Chat Room,” etc.) at local computer 102,                  
          Sanderman does not teach designating a deepest node level of the            
          tree structure.  It is argued that by designating a deepest node            
          level in the instant invention, only a selected number of                   
          documents are downloaded into the memory of the local computer              
          system, i.e., only the documents in the nodes on levels that are            
          in and between the root node and the node of the deepest level so           
          designated, and so download time and memory space on the local              
          computer system are conserved.                                              
               Appellants also argue that Sanderman fails to teach                    
          “downloading, into the memory of the local computer system,                 
          documents in the nodes on levels that are in and between the root           
          node and the node at the deepest node level.”  Appellants state             
          that, contrary to the examiner’s position, Hughes does not teach            
          this limitation and, even if it did, it would result in all of              
          the network information being downloaded to the local computer              
          because Hughes does not designate a deepest node level of the               
                                         -7–                                          




Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007