Ex Parte MAKUTONIN et al - Page 4



          Appeal No. 2002-1058                                                        
          Application 09/228,856                                                      

          strip 17 of pouches from an upstream pouch form, fill and seal              
          machine, a cutting wheel 11 which cooperates with the index wheel           
          to cut the pouch train into individual pouches 18, a transfer               
          wheel 21 for receiving the individual pouches from the index                
          wheel, and a multiple lane pouch conveyor 19 for receiving the              
          pouches from the transfer wheel and transporting them to a                  
          downstream packaging (e.g., cartoning) apparatus.  The index and            
          cutting wheels include blades 14 and 12 which cooperate in                  
          scissor-like fashion to sever the individual pouches from the               
          pouch train or strip, and the index and transfer wheels include             
          suction heads 15 and 22 for holding and releasing the individual            
          pouches as they travel from the index wheel to the transfer wheel           
          and then to the multiple lane pouch conveyor.  Figure 1 shows               
          that the multiple lane pouch conveyor extends parallel to the               
          axes of the index and transfer wheels.                                      
               As conceded by the examiner (see pages 3 through 5 in the              
          answer), Scarpa fails to respond to the limitations in                      
          independent claim 1, and the corresponding limitations in                   
          independent claims 16, 24, 35 and 36, requiring at least two                
          conveyors for receiving individual pouches after severing wherein           
          at least one of the conveyors is a direct drop bucket conveyor              
          extending from the transfer apparatus in a direction                        

                                          4                                           



Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007