Ex Parte DEARN - Page 3


                Appeal No. 2002-1254                                                  Page 3                  
                Application No. 09/411,381                                                                    

                and liposomal systems and has . . . been used for cell-rupture purposes in                    
                biotechnology applications.”  Id.                                                             
                                                 Discussion                                                   
                      Claims 20 and 21 are directed to particles of atovaquone where at least                 
                90% of the particles have a volume diameter between 0.1 and 3 µm (claim 20),                  
                or in which the particles have been microfluidized (claim 21).  The examiner                  
                rejected claims 20-27, 30, and 31 as anticipated by Latter, on the basis that                 
                      Latter et al. teach atovaquone having a diameter of 0.5 to 7 microns                    
                      (col. 2, line[s] 32-47; col. 5, lines 19-23).  The reference teaches (1)                
                      the compound exhibits good activity against Pneumocystis carinii                        
                      pneumonia infections . . . and (2) various formulation[s] including                     
                      suspensions. . . .  The compound, composition and method of use                         
                      taught by the reference are encompassed by the instant claims.                          
                Examiner’s Answer, page 3.                                                                    
                      As the examiner noted, Latter discloses treatment of Pneumocystis carinii               
                pneumonia with atovaquone.  (Latter refers to atovaquone by its chemical name.                
                Compare Latter, col. 2, lines 32-33, with the instant specification, page 1, first            
                paragraph.)  Latter also discloses that “[f]ormulations suitable for pulmonary                
                administration via the buccal cavity are presented such that particles containing             
                the active ingredient and desirably having a diameter in the range of 0.5 to 7                
                microns are delivered into the bronchial tree of the recipient.”  Col. 5, lines 19-23.        
                Latter also discloses exemplary formulations for “Nebulisation,” “Aerosol                     
                Formulation,” and “Powder Inhalation,” all of which contain “micronised”                      
                atovaquone.  See col. 8, line 60 to column 9, line 46.                                        








Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007