Ex Parte Flick - Page 7




          Appeal No. 2002-1470                                   Page 7               
          Application No. 09/490,192                                                  


          appellant intended to refer to a data communication bus for                 
          controlling vehicle devices, such as the engine, in addition to             
          the vehicle alerting system, claim 1 as broadly drafted, reads on           
          the data communications bus 64 within the controller 34 of                  
          Grossheim.                                                                  
               As shown in figure 2 of Grossheim, bus 64 communicates data            
          from the alarm sensors (via data latch 66) and microprocessor 60,           
          to data latches 76, 78, and 80, which, through interface 88,                
          connect to pager 56.  As data bus 64 is within controller 34, it            
          inherently extends within vehicle 12, as advanced by the                    
          examiner.  Grossheim further discloses (col. 10, lines 47-55)               
          that:                                                                       
               a paging unit 56 may optionally be connected to                        
               the control unit 34 to provide remote paging                           
               capabilities should a violation be detected.                           
               Such paging unit 56 transmits a prescribed signal,                     
               through antenna 58, to a remote receiver (not shown)                   
               in order to signal the alarm condition.  The remote                    
               receiver is typically carried by the owner and emits                   
               a beeping sound when being paged, thereby notifying                    
               the owner that a violation has occurred.                               
          Because the pager transmits a signal through antenna 58 to a                
          remote receiver (not shown), which is typically carried by the              
          owner, we find that Grossheim includes a paging controller to               
          control the transmitting of the alarm signals.  In addition,                









Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007