Ex Parte GRANNEMAN et al - Page 3




          Appeal No. 2002-1760                                                        
          Serial No. 09/355,509                                                       
          containing two reactors, a turntable, and devices for                       
          transferring semiconductor wafers between each reactor and the              
          turntable.  Claim 20 requires a two-level processing chamber                
          having first and second reactors on the upper level, first and              
          second elevators for lifting a boat from first and second                   
          positions on the lower level into, respectively, the first and              
          second reactors, and a boat transfer mechanism on the lower level           
          for transferring a boat within the processing chamber from at               
          least the first position to at least the second position on the             
          lower level.  Claim 31 requires a processing chamber having                 
          therein a boat transfer mechanism, at least two reactors                    
          occupying the same defined footprint as the boat transfer                   
          mechanism, and a boat lift mechanism for lifting boats from the             
          boat transfer mechanism into one of the reactors.                           
               Zinger discloses a semiconductor processing apparatus which            
          differs from that claimed in the appellants’ independent claims             
          only in that Zinger’s processing chambers (10, 11 and 12) each              
          contain only one reactor and lift mechanism.  Zinger’s processing           
          chambers each have three compartments and a rotary table (14) for           
          transferring wafers among the compartments (figure 1).  The                 
          compartments are 1) a compartment for loading and unloading wafer           
          carriers by moving them between a transfer station (8) and the              
          compartment, 2) a compartment containing a reactor above the                

                                          3                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007