Ex Parte IKEDA - Page 6




          Appeal No. 2002-1831                                                         
          Application No. 08/841,320                                                   


          transferring line for training an operator in processes related              
          to assembling auto-parts comprising, inter alia a first                      
          transferring loop line guiding a plurality of transferring                   
          carriages, a second transferring loop line guiding units of the              
          suspension frames transferring means, and transferring means for             
          transferring an automobile body between the first and second                 
          loops.3                                                                      


               A reading of the overall Nokajima reference reveals to us               
          that claims 1 and 7 are anticipated thereby.  In particular, the             
          vehicle body assembling line Li (automobile assembly line) of                
          Nokajima (Fig. 10) is understood as being apart from a vehicle               
          body Bo transporting overhead conveyor (a main long automobile               
          body transferring line); column 9, lines 21 through 24.  As                  
          discerned from the reference (Fig. 10), travel carriages Tr                  
          (transferring carriages) travel a first closed loop (zones ABCDE,            
          turntables 90,91,92, and 93, zones IJKLMA, and turntables                    
          102,103) and trolleys 86 (suspension frames or means) travel an              
          overhead second closed loop (zones EFGI, transporting rail 82,               

               3 We understand "the units of the suspension frames                     
          transferring means" to correspond to the earlier set forth                   
          "plurality of suspension type transferring means."  However,                 
          during any further prosecution before the examiner, the above                
          disparity should be addressed.                                               
                                          6                                            





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007