Ex Parte HELLER et al - Page 6




          Appeal No. 2002-1916                                                        
          Application 09/332,772                                                      


          guidewire and dilator (93) are removed so that catheters or                 
          other medical devices can then be passed through the lumen of the           
          catheter member (20) into the desired vessel.  Thus, the adapter            
          (93) need not be positioned within the lumen of catheter member             
          (20) at all times and the user clearly has the option of removing           
          it or not when appropriate.  We are also of the view that a                 
          further guidewire of a size on the order of the outside diameter            
          of adapter (93) or smaller would reasonably fall within the                 
          bounds of “other medical devices” to be passed through the                  
          catheter member (20) and into the blood vessel as mentioned                 
          in Donadio (col. 3, lines 5-7).                                             


                    Contrary to appellants’ arguments in their brief                  
          (pages 8-9) and reply brief (page 3), we consider that Donadio              
          clearly discloses a catheter member (20) having a lumen which is            
          capable of accommodating a first guidewire having an external               
          diameter of a given size and also guidewires of different                   
          diameters, wherein the guidewire diameters may fall within a                
          range slightly smaller than the outer diameter of adapter (93)              
          to just larger than the outer diameter of the guidewire (95).               



                                          6                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007