Ex Parte WILLIAMSON et al - Page 8




          Appeal No. 2002-2073                                                        
          Application No. 09/210,104                                 Page 8           


          amended claims expressly recite that the Execution Trace Facility           
          is inserted into the code of the program in a 'disabled mode' and           
          thereafter enabled 'only' in response to a determination that a             
          malfunction of the program has occurred."  Appellants assert                
          (id.) that Borchardt “fails to show or suggest in any way the               
          inclusion of an Execution Trace Facility within a program in a              
          disabled mode which may then be selectively enabled upon a                  
          determination that an error has occurred.”  In addition,                    
          appellants (brief, pages 5 and 6) dispute the examiner's                    
          assertion that Mann discloses a software debug facility, arguing            
          that Mann discloses a debug controlled software program 112 which           
          is executed by host system 111, which controls the extraction and           
          analysis of debug information generated by the target system 101,           
          and that Mann teaches a hardware system which must be coupled to            
          the system under test via a debug port to execute a test of the             
          software within the target system.                                          
               It is further argued (brief, page 6) that “no combination of           
          Mann and Borchardt, et al., is appropriate, and even if such a              
          combination is appropriate, that combination cannot be said to              
          show or suggest the insertion of an Execution Trace Facility in a           
          ‘disabled’ mode ‘into the code of the program ...’ which is                 
          thereafter recompiled and operated ‘in a normal operating                   







Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007