Ex Parte LYLE et al - Page 6




          Appeal No. 2002-2218                                                        
          Application 09/322,698                                                      


          which of necessity require write operations.  The first paragraph           
          of the Summary of the Invention at column 3 of Mohan clearly is             
          in the context of log sequence numbers (LSNs) relating to                   
          identifiers associated with modifications to data in the same               
          manner as just noted.  Thus, the focus of Mohan's teachings does            
          not appear to be upon any read transactions.                                
               In fact, as noted by appellants at the top of page 12 of the           
          principal brief on appeal, Mohan specifically teaches at column             
          6, lines 62 and 63 that "Read-only transactions do not do any               
          logging."  To the extent such read-only operations convey the               
          absence of updates or changes or modifications to a database,               
          this portion of Mohan may be considered to teach away from the              
          use of read-identifiers and their storage, where the read                   
          identifiers reflect a time at which a reading transaction as                
          claimed first accesses an object in a database and then later is            
          used to determine an age of an oldest active reading transaction.           
          Based upon the quoted teaching, there appears to be no log                  
          sequence number (LSN) generated in Mohan for read-only                      
          operations.  Lastly, column 6, lines 60-62 essentially defines              
          updates as an "update transaction writes a ... record just before           
          performing its first update."                                               


                                          6                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007