Ex Parte HAYNES et al - Page 5


               Appeal No. 2002-2246                                                                                                   
               Application No. 09/192,110                                                                                             


               Pike discloses the split fibers are suitable for various uses including disposable articles, e.g.,                     
               protective garments, sterilization wraps, wiper cloth and covers for absorbent articles.  (Col.                        
               10).  Pike discloses the filaments can be laminated to other layers.  (Cols. 10-11).  Pike                             
               discloses the bicomponent filaments are dried prior to bonding to other layers.  (Col. 9).                             
               Pike does not disclose the additional layer is combined with the bicomponent filaments prior                           
               to splitting.                                                                                                          
                       Hansen discloses the bicomponent fibers are eccentrically, concentrically or side-by-                          
               side type.  (Col. 3).  Hansen discloses the bicomponent filaments are bound to other fibers                            
               including superabsorbent polymers.  (Col. 5).  However, Hansen does not discloses the                                  
               bicomponents filaments are splitable.  Thus, Hansen does not disclose the bicomponents                                 
               filaments are bound to absorbent fibers and/or superabsorbent particles prior to splitting.                            
                       We are not convinced that it would have been obvious to include fibers and particles                           
               in the nonwoven composite of Pike as suggested by the Examiner.  The Examiner has not                                  
               directed us to a basis for adding a third component to the filaments prior to splitting so as to                       
               incorporate the third component within the matrix of Pike.  Pike discloses the lamination of                           
               the split filaments to additional layers.  However, these layers are added to the filaments                            
               after the matrix has been formed and are not incorporated within the matrix.                                           






                                                                  5                                                                   



Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007